Tuesday, October 30, 2007
《色,戒》- 既非漢奸文學更非漢奸電影
這一陣《色,戒》是個熱門話題個方意見有褒有貶。貶的部份大多不外乎張愛玲曾嫁了個大漢奸胡蘭成﹐而《色,戒》既未伸張“正義”﹐又未突顯抗日烈士的“大義秉然”。這種說法其實也無新意﹐在《色,戒》最初刊登時就曾被帶過漢奸文學的大帽子。在一個教條主義的時代﹐這種狹隘的思維並不希奇﹐但在今日仍有這種想法實在可悲。
我們可以不欣賞張愛玲或她的作品。但我們不能因在《色,戒》中可以看到張愛玲及胡蘭成的影子就說它是漢奸文學。我們更不能因它刻劃了人性脆弱及黑暗的一面就得戴上道學及教條的面具來撻伐它。
至於李安的電影就更說不上是漢奸電影。今天有太多剛愎自用的棒槌﹐連電影都沒看就妄加評論。電影其實已加重了對日軍及漢奸負面的描繪。當然這對那些樣板戲死忠的井底蛙來說是遠遠不夠的。作為堀起的大國民﹐愛國應是建築在對影人性又這更深沉的體會而非膚淺教條。膚淺教條式愛國的脆弱在汪精衛及丁默村已有明證﹐我們無須重蹈歷史的覆轍。
我們可以不欣賞張愛玲或她的作品。但我們不能因在《色,戒》中可以看到張愛玲及胡蘭成的影子就說它是漢奸文學。我們更不能因它刻劃了人性脆弱及黑暗的一面就得戴上道學及教條的面具來撻伐它。
至於李安的電影就更說不上是漢奸電影。今天有太多剛愎自用的棒槌﹐連電影都沒看就妄加評論。電影其實已加重了對日軍及漢奸負面的描繪。當然這對那些樣板戲死忠的井底蛙來說是遠遠不夠的。作為堀起的大國民﹐愛國應是建築在對影人性又這更深沉的體會而非膚淺教條。膚淺教條式愛國的脆弱在汪精衛及丁默村已有明證﹐我們無須重蹈歷史的覆轍。
Thursday, October 25, 2007
Review of "Lust, Caution"
The reviews of “Lust, Caution” have been a mixed one. Many blamed the reviewers who have given the movie poor rating been lacking knowledge of Chinese culture or war time history.
While knowledge of the historical background certainly can be a factor, a bigger problem is this movie has been inaccurately promoted by its distributor Focus Features. They are promoting it as an “espionage thriller” and as result, almost all the movie web sites following when in fact, this movie is neither a spy nor a thriller film. It is a drama of human emotion. Any one expecting an action filled movie with a beautiful spy because they think this is an “erotic espionage thriller “ as proclaimed on Focus Feature’s web site will surly be disappointed and bored. If action filled shoot out movie is what you are looking for, you probably should not bother to see this film. The same can be said if you are looking for a shoot it out war movie.
If you like fairly tale happy ending or, at very least, “justice” triumph at the end, this movie may not be right for you either. Real life unfortunately is full of tragedies. War is tragedy. People died in war. The base frame work of story was the real failed assassination attempts on the head of secrete police and top collaborator by Shanghai socialite Zheng Ping Ru in 1939. She was only 22 when she was executed. People also got emotional scars in war. In some way, author Eileen Chang’s own marriage to another high ranking collaborator is a tragedy too. The stigma of been a “collaborator’s wife” persists even after her death. The complex emotion of lead character Wang Chia Chi towards Mr. Yee probably reflects author’s own emotion and experience. The mood of the film is therefore “melancholy”. A word Ang Lee likes to use often.
Understanding of Chinese war history is not essential. One can easily substitute Shanghai with Paris or Warsaw; Chinese with French or Polish and Japanese with Nazi and made the same movie. Knowing Eileen Chang’s background however, helps to understand Wang Chia Chi and Mr. Yee. If you find the notion of a “good girl” fall for a collaborator repulsive, stay away.
If none of those factors deter you, you probably will like this movie as it certainly is far above average film these days. If you like human drama film, this one is for you. If you like great acting with subtle body language and facial expression, you should not miss this one.
While knowledge of the historical background certainly can be a factor, a bigger problem is this movie has been inaccurately promoted by its distributor Focus Features. They are promoting it as an “espionage thriller” and as result, almost all the movie web sites following when in fact, this movie is neither a spy nor a thriller film. It is a drama of human emotion. Any one expecting an action filled movie with a beautiful spy because they think this is an “erotic espionage thriller “ as proclaimed on Focus Feature’s web site will surly be disappointed and bored. If action filled shoot out movie is what you are looking for, you probably should not bother to see this film. The same can be said if you are looking for a shoot it out war movie.
If you like fairly tale happy ending or, at very least, “justice” triumph at the end, this movie may not be right for you either. Real life unfortunately is full of tragedies. War is tragedy. People died in war. The base frame work of story was the real failed assassination attempts on the head of secrete police and top collaborator by Shanghai socialite Zheng Ping Ru in 1939. She was only 22 when she was executed. People also got emotional scars in war. In some way, author Eileen Chang’s own marriage to another high ranking collaborator is a tragedy too. The stigma of been a “collaborator’s wife” persists even after her death. The complex emotion of lead character Wang Chia Chi towards Mr. Yee probably reflects author’s own emotion and experience. The mood of the film is therefore “melancholy”. A word Ang Lee likes to use often.
Understanding of Chinese war history is not essential. One can easily substitute Shanghai with Paris or Warsaw; Chinese with French or Polish and Japanese with Nazi and made the same movie. Knowing Eileen Chang’s background however, helps to understand Wang Chia Chi and Mr. Yee. If you find the notion of a “good girl” fall for a collaborator repulsive, stay away.
If none of those factors deter you, you probably will like this movie as it certainly is far above average film these days. If you like human drama film, this one is for you. If you like great acting with subtle body language and facial expression, you should not miss this one.
Thursday, October 18, 2007
Four Entangled Life –The Real People Behind "Lust, Caution"
Wednesday, October 10, 2007
Lust, Caution (色,戒) News Items
- 《色戒》香港票房已达3000万 参赛金像奖又遭拒
- 《色.戒》韩国上映 18岁以上可观看内容未删减
- 色,戒台灣票房4連霸 - 10/23/07
- 北京新世纪、新东安影院《色,戒》倒计时抢票
- Cautious US Strategy for Ang Lee Film - AP 10/23/07
- What Fuels Ang Lee's 'Lust' in America? 10/22/07
- Variety Honors 2007 ‘10 Actors to Watch’ - 10/22/07
- Taiwan withdraws Lee's film from Oscars - AP 10/18/07
- "Lust, Caution" postponed again - People's Daily 10/12/07
- Taipei audiences lusting after Lee's film `Lust, Caution' - Taipei Times 10/9/07
- 《色戒》香港票房超2000万 台湾首周破亿元台币- 南方都市报 10/9/07
- 香港票房综述:《色,戒》连庄戒色不戒票房 - 新浪娱乐
- Throwing 'Lust, Caution' to the wind - Mercury News 10/7/07
- Ang Lee, Laura Linney open Mill Valley Film Festival - San Francisco Chronicle 10/6/07
- 'Lust, Caution' Box Office Hit in Taiwan - AP 10/5/07
- 搭「色‧戒」風 國民黨揭情報檔案 - TVBS 10/4/07
- GOOD AS GOLD - San Francisco Chronicle 9/30/07
- Ang Lee's latest breaks Far East box office records - MRIB 9/28/07
- Ang Lee's 'Lust,' built on trust - LA Times 9/23/07
- 電影「色‧戒」女烈士 真有其人!- TVBS 9/23/07
- 三联生活周刊:张爱玲与郑苹如的命运交叉 9/20/07
Friday, October 5, 2007
Lust, Caution (色,戒) Coverage
- Offical Chinese Web Site 中文官方網站
- Box Office
- IMDB
- LA Times Review
- Mercury News
- National Post
- NY Times Movies
- Outnow
- Philadelphia Inquirer
- Rotten Tomatoes
- Sacramento Bee
- Slate
- Time
- The Times BFI 51st London Film Festival
- Wikipedia
- Yahoo! Movies
- Yahoo! UK & Ireland Movies
- 新浪影音娱乐
- 搜狐娱乐
- 博偉影痴俱樂部
- 新华网
- Yahoo!奇摩電影
- Yahoo! 中国雅虎娱乐
- Yahoo! 雅虎香港電影
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)